As news of the Oct. 23, 2011, jet fighters' alleged interception and shoot-down of an intrusive UFO near the naval air base at Pensacola, Fla., was finding a niche on the internet, what official records of the event were being created within the U. S. Navy's chain of command?To find out, I fired off a freedom-of-information request to the Navy (Item 2.135, dated Nov. 6, 2011). Several days later, I received a kiss-off "no records" response from the NASP FOIA officer. Unsatisfied with such short shrift, I followed up, on November 13, 2011 (Item 2.139), with a FOIA request for the entire NASP FOIA case file on my original request. Here's what the file reveals, starting with its Dec. 1, 2011, letter of transmittal from Lt. Eden:
Dear Mr. Bryant:
This letter responds to your Freedom of Information Act request dated November 13, 2011, in which you sought a copy of records maintained by Naval Air Station Pensacola, Florida regarding an Anti-UFO Attack on October 23, 2011. Your request was received in this office on November 28, 2011 and was assigned file number 12-11.
Naval Air Station Pensacola, Base Air Operations was contacted to search for documents responsive to your request. After a complete review of aviation logs and records it was determined that no flight operations were conducted during the time period that you requested. A thorough search of our records failed to disclose any additional records responsive to your request.
The requested information is partially exempt from disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act. Primarily the information exempted falls under exemption (b)(6), which protects personal privacy. Specifically, we are unable to provide you with the information of individuals contained in the document because release of this information would be an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy [5 U.S.C. Sec. 552(b)(6)].
Enclosure (1) is a redacted copy of emails from FOIA file 12-05. Other documents in the file are your original request and the response letter dated November 8, 2011.
Enclosure (2) is a copy of the UFO Fact Sheet. This sheet is also available at http://www.foia.navy.mil , the Navy FOIA Reading Room. The UFO Fact Sheet provides additional information that may be of assistance to you. If you feel that the search of the records was not complete, you may appeal this determination in writing to: Judge Advocate General of the Navy (Code 14), 1322 Patterson Avenue, S. E. - Suite 3000, Washington Navy Yard, DC 20374-5066.
Your appeal must be postmarked within 60 calendar days from the date of this letter. A statement as to why your appeal should be granted should be included and a copy of this letter should be attached. Both the appeal letter and the envelope should bear the notation, "Freedom of Information Act Appeal."
There are no fees associated with this request. Any questions concerning this matter should be directed to Ms. Joanne Parra at (904) 542-4026.
Sincerely,
G. W. EDEN
Lieutenant
Judge Advocate General's Corps
U. S. Navy
By direction of the Commander
Enclosure: 1. Email from FOIA file 12-05 (redacted)
2. UFO Fact Sheet
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Here is the text of each e-mail printout provided in Eden's Dec. 1 letter, beginning with Nov. 7 and ending with Nov. 8:
(1) Nov. 7 [to someone in Jacksonville, Fla.]: Good morning and hope you had a great weekend. We have a FOIA request seeking records from NAS Pensacola. Not sure if you all have any responsive records, but is it ok to forward along to you?
(2) Nov. 7 [from someone in Jacksonville]: Good morning. Can you look over this FOIA request and see who at NAS Pensacola could assist? Thank you for your help.
(3) Nov. 7 [from a paralegal specialist in the Region Legal Service Office, SE Branch Office - Naval Air Station Pensacola]: Please find below in the string of emails a FOIA request for Anti-UFO Attack from Naval Air Station Pensacola. Since this involves Jet Planes, I assume that this will go to [deleted] but just wanted to run it by you first. Any information you could provide would be greatly appreciated.
(4) Nov. 7 [from NAS Pensacola, N31]: Not sure how to respond to this -- I don't know of anything related to this request.
(5) Nov. 8 [from Southeast to NAS Pensacola, N31]: The only thing that I will need to forward to the region is a list of anyone that was flying on 23 October 2011. If you have that information that would be great. Thanks.
(6) Nov. 8 [from NAS Pensacola, N31 to NAS Pensacola N3; ACCS NAS Pensacola, N3; and NAS Pensacola, N31]: ATC [Air Traffic Control?], Do you have any records to provide for the below request?
(7) Nov. 8 [from NAS Pensacola, N31 to NAS Pensacola, N31; NAS Pensacola, N3; and ACCS NAS Pensacola, N3]: I have checked all aviation logs and records in Base Operations/Transient Line. We did not have a fighter aircraft aboard NAS Pensacola during this timeframe. NAS Pensacola wouldn't have the capability since we only have training aircraft here.
(8) Nov. 8 [from Southeast to Jacksonville]: This is the response that I got from our AIROPS folks. Please let me know if you need anything else. Talk to you soon.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Lt. Eden's enclosed copy of the (undated) two-page UFO Fact Sheet begins with this disclaimer: "There is no central office or activity in the Department of the Navy assigned the mission of collecting and maintaining information on UFO phenomenon, paranormal activity, and/or similar events." It goes on to summarize the Air Force's historical role in UFOlogy, dating back through the 1950s--1960s-era Project Blue Book to the Roswell (N.M.) "flying disc" retrieval operation of July 1947. But it neglects to mention that some of the debris from the Roswell UFO crash-landing was shared with certain Navy authorities (according to the late Army intelligence officer Lt. Col. Philip J. Corso's memoir The Day After Roswell). Plus: the "fact sheet" conveniently ignores that, to this very day, the Navy (as well as the other uniformed services) remains obligated, via Joint Army-Navy-Air Publication 146 ("Communications Instructions for Reporting Vital Intelligence Sightings"), to collect and process any UFO-sighting reports by its personnel.
Meantime, I wonder whether the jet interceptors on that fateful day of October 23, 2011, originated from Florida's Homestead Air Reserve Base. Will any USAF whistleblowers in this case please step forward and perform a valuable service to the public's right-to-know and the government's duty-to-tell?